I shot the Lucky for a couple years. Only issue I ever had was when it got dirty the trigger wouldn’t release right away. I would squeeze it and nothing would happen until I was letting down, then it would go off. I cleaned the hell out of it, soaking in the sink. Never had a problem since. I love Carters. Just wanted to pitch that in.
I had a Like Mike cost me a 200” Muley a few years back. Release wouldn’t fire due to the magnets picking up tiny pieces of grit on the stalk. Sold it and never looked back. Went back to my trusty Scott.
I had a Carter Like Mike and Quickie. They were both great but I really liked the Quickie because of the curved trigger and shorter head. Sold both though to shoot hand-helds, and I stuck with Carter.
I had the same problem as Jordan with the Carter Lucky. Mine locked up during a backpack hunt. Fortunately I had an old Scott Little Bitty Goose as a backup that saved the hunt. I blamed the lock-up on the magnets. Carter exchanged it for a Quickie+ and I have been very happy with it going on 5 years.
They don't make it any longer, but I have the Carter Squeeze me. You can still find them on the internet. It's a tank of a release, but if you want a true back tension release that can't be released other than with back tension and still want the index, it's ideal. Never had a problem with it locking up or any such thing.