Dedicated Turkey Gun - 3" or 3.5"?

Brendan

WKR
Joined
Aug 27, 2013
Messages
3,871
Location
Massachusetts
If you were going to pick up a new semi-auto as a dedicated turkey gun, is there any real advantage to a 3.5" gun over a 3" gun? Any reason I shouldn't get a 3.5"? I'm thinking about patterns, available ammo, effective range, etc.

Generally I'd like to maximize the effective range of the gun, paired with a dedicated turkey choke, good ammo, a red dot, and some pattern testing. I'm also aware of the trade-off that a dense pattern at longer range means you have to be much more precise at short range.

Probably can't go wrong with either, but want to hear what you think...
 

johnsd16

WKR
Joined
Mar 14, 2016
Messages
336
Location
North Idaho
In my mind there is absolutely no question that the 3.5” is an advantage for turkey. If buying it dedicated for turkey I would no question go 3.5”. With that said, ammo and chokes have come a long ways and the gap IMO between a well thought out and tuned 3” setup and a similarly thought out 3.5” setup is less now than it was 15 yrs ago. Turkeys are tough and one or two more pellets in the right places can mean a lot. Recoil is a non-issue in a turkey gun I think as well, it is not high volume shooting as can be the case with waterfowl. That is all good rationale for going to up 10ga as well but the options for guns, ammo and chokes is also more limited so to me the incremental benefit of a 10ga is overshadowed by those shortcomings.
 

bates

WKR
Joined
Sep 4, 2012
Messages
554
Location
Florida
With modern ammo I personally see no reason for either


If I was setting up a dedicated turkey which i am I’m going 20 gauge


I just don’t see the point now of a 12. But I’m also shooting tss ammo and putting an rmr on it

To this point I’ve only used 12’s but a 20 is so light and handy and now that tss is available loaded
This makes a 20 even more appealing.

But if you don’t want to spend the money for tss then I probably wouldn’t go 20.

As far a 12’s 3inch is plenty. I just patterned my old 870. With #9 tss and a .660 Indian creek I put 494 pellets in a 10 inch circle at 40 yards

But I can also take hevi 7’s or long beard 6’s and kill birds at 50 yards all day long. For the money long beard xr is. Nasty. I get a more open pattern with the hevi 7 though

Red dots are awesome front and rear rifle type sights are mandatory on a gobbler gun for me.
 

mlob1one

WKR
Joined
Mar 18, 2015
Messages
430
I can't comment on the patterning.
For ammo the 3" is way more prevalent.

I have found that a really good choke has dramatically improved my grouping out to 70 yards.

I can tell you that a 3.5" turkey load is not something you want to shoot more than a couple times in a day because the recoil can be punishing.

Good luck on your quest for the perfect turkey gun.

Sent from my SM-G935P using Tapatalk
 
Joined
Sep 18, 2016
Messages
688
Location
Maryland
I would think with 3" you would have a better re-sale potential and if you are buying a semi you could water fowl with it as well. As others have stated with chokes and ammo it's probably a fairly even field. I like to get em close, a 20 gauge makes it a challenge but lugging a semi 12 for miles even with a sling can be a PIA.
 

N2TRKYS

WKR
Joined
Apr 17, 2016
Messages
3,954
Location
Alabama
I've been loading TSS for a couple of years now and have an 870 20ga. However, I still like my 12ga 3.5" 870. I don't notice much difference in recoil between my 12ga and my lightweight 20ga. Carrying the 12ga doesn't bother me, either. The only difference I notice is the barrel length. My 20ga has a shorter barrel, which makes it handier once setup. If I changed barrels on my 12, then this would be a push, as well.

Good luck with whatever you decide.
 
OP
Brendan

Brendan

WKR
Joined
Aug 27, 2013
Messages
3,871
Location
Massachusetts
Sounds like a range of opinions - I guess it's like every other gun or bow out there :D

Any Beretta A400 Fans out there? With a 26" barrel, camo'd/dipped from the factory, could very easily pull double duty as a waterfowl gun and shoots everything from 2-3/4" to 3.5" shells. I have one of their O/U's and I'm a fan...
 
Joined
Feb 26, 2012
Messages
3,234
Location
Some wilderness area, somewhere
My preference would be a 20ga with TSS, second would be a 20ga with Hevi 13, third would be the 3" 12ga. When you are averaging over 250 pellets in a 10" circle at 40 yards it more or less makes the 3.5" irrelevant.....unless you just want more recoil/shot.
 

bowhnt

Lil-Rokslider
Joined
May 8, 2017
Messages
289
Location
michigan
My preference would be a 20ga with TSS, second would be a 20ga with Hevi 13, third would be the 3" 12ga. When you are averaging over 250 pellets in a 10" circle at 40 yards it more or less makes the 3.5" irrelevant.....unless you just want more recoil/shot.

One day I’m gonna get around to loading up some tss for my 10 gauge. Mostly just cuz I can.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

Nuke Man

WKR
Joined
May 1, 2014
Messages
553
Location
Midwest
Most semi auto 12 gauge shotguns (all that I own anyways) will shoot 3 or 3.5. With that, I always head to the turkey woods with 3.5's. They group better and hold there pattern better for me. Plus with a gas operated semi auto you can't tell a difference in recoil. If you were using a pump, then most definitely you can.
 
Joined
Feb 12, 2018
Messages
310
Location
Kansas City
3.5" Winchester xtended range has killed a lot of birds for me. Always has patterned better than hevishot out of my sbe2 with just a full choke

Sent from my XT1710-02 using Tapatalk
 

OG DramaLlama

Epic Rokslider
Joined
May 9, 2015
Messages
423
Location
Boise
I shoot a benelli supernova. Tested 3” and 3.5” Long Beard XR’s.

Went with the 3”.

Tested others but that shell was the best factory round I could.

Here are the results from my pattern tests last spring.

running with the .650 Carlson Choke.

Winchester Long Beards:

- 3.5" 2oz #6
- 3" 1 3/4oz #6

Opened one shell of each to get a pellet count. The 3.5" had 466 pellets and the 3" had 420. Admittedly, it was very difficult to get an accurate count as the substance used to hold pellets together makes it very difficult.

It is interesting how well the pellets stay together and how difficult it is to pull them apart. Here is a picture of the pellets cut from shell.

8998c5d359a36d444b3b5625df12a2cb.jpg



@30 yards

The results were impressive . The killing area of both targets was too openes up to get accurate count. After six shots the cardboard backing was completely blown away. Granted, this cardboard has already been used for all prior testing so could be just a function of being over used. Nonetheless, saw nothing like this with any of my other tests.

5b6a8aa30437aa2a301aebf1e167f9dd.jpg


@ 40 Yards

Long Beard 3.5"

- 10.6 Pellets in the killing zone
- 12.89% Choke Efficiency

Long Beard 3"

- 16 Pellets in the killing zones
- 22% Choke Efficiency


Conclusion: The Long Beards had better results than other tests. Hard to explain the difference between the 3" and 3.5" at 40 yards. I shot the 3.5" first and the kick difference is noticeable. Could be influencing my shooting. Because of this, I will run with 3" Long Beards this spring. Feel extremely comfortable with my maximum effective range of 40 yards. With more testing and comfort with this gun may be able to go a little bit further. Might do some more at longer ranges just to see, but part of the fun is getting them close (for me at least


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Joined
Dec 17, 2017
Messages
941
Location
N Idaho
Ive shot the 3" longbeards. They shot fine, even have and shot a bunch of premium blend hevishot 5,6,7 and most things in between. Cant say anything has ever patterned better than 3" copper plated federal #5's. Cheapest ones and ive shot a truck load of birds with them. Love the 835.
 

bradb

WKR
Joined
Jan 8, 2013
Messages
959
In the smaller bore 12 s we are often trying to push to much down to small a diameter barrel. Don't get me wrong the 3.5's still can work good, but maybe bot much gain over the 3". In a overbore barrel like the mosseberg the 3.5 is a better match. Really is personal choice and what testing shows you. I do much prefer to grab my Weatherby sa 08 youth 20 gauge, I in no way feel handicapped to my 3.5 12.
 

FLAK

WKR
Joined
Jan 22, 2014
Messages
2,287
Location
Gulf Coast
My 13 y/o is set up with a youth 20 shooting 3" Hevi 7's.
He killed his first longbeard with a Browning Sweet 16 with #6 Pheasant loads. DRT.
 

boom

WKR
Joined
Sep 11, 2013
Messages
3,185
my local birds come in close!! i could kill one with a dove load.

having said that, i use 3" shells. Hevishot stuff. it's the thing i use when i have exhausted all my other efforts with my bow or pellet gun. i like the 3" because it is easy to find in my area. i need non-toxic
 

andyfier

FNG
Joined
Feb 14, 2018
Messages
59
I don't shoot a semi auto, but my 870 'super mag sps turkey' shoots the long beard xr 3.5's awesome. With the standard Remington turkey choke I can shoot much further than I ever imagined. I started turkey hunting with a 2 3/4 chamber single shot 20 with a full choke and the cheapest turkey shells around. I've shot the smallest legal shell all the way up the 3.5s
I don't go gun hunting turkey without the 3.5 12's now.

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
 

gdog

Lil-Rokslider
Joined
Mar 4, 2016
Messages
297
Location
Sandy UT
20ga. Not sure why you would need anything more if your actually calling them in to close range. I've shot enough turkeys that if I can't get them in close...I just don't shoot. Actually toying around with the idea of breaking out the 28ga this Spring.
 

cjl32

Lil-Rokslider
Joined
Mar 31, 2016
Messages
144
Location
MS
With the newer generation long range shells and a decent choke, a 3" gun should easily give you clean kills at 50 yds. My setup is deadly at 65 yds with the Winchester 3" XR #5's and the Carlson's XR specific choke. I'm shooting a 3" Benelli Super 90 with 21" barrel. You will likely want adjustable sights as the pattern at 30yds is still 6" or smaller for me. Never thought I would need a range finder for turkey hunting.
 
Top