It might not be quite as good as the Mil but still better than most other MOA FFP reticles and usable on low powers. I went with it because it was available and like it.
By 23 combined points do you mean you each have 23 or together you have 23. WY averages points between party application members so you would have 12.5 points as a hunting party.
No, the 1” 3-15? did and didn’t pass but may have been previously damaged from improper mounting. I think someone on 24hr CF did do a drop test of the 2.5-15 30mm Tract and it faired better.