Appreciate the feedback...been going back and forth between the Hatch and the Atlas. Tough to swallow the price tag but once I do, I know it will be well worth the investment.
I had issues with the Idaho’s as well. The insoles helped but found that the toe box was too big for my foot. Went with the Briksdal’s and haven’t looked back. Also, the rubber portions of Idaho started breaking down/cracking through after just 1 season.
The Idaho for me has a wide toe box which causes my foot to slip when side hilling. No matter how I laced or how tight I tried to get the laces, they would cause hot spots. The Briksdal is a stiffer shanked boot but it fits my foot like a glove.