Muley Buck
WKR
Honestly, I would expect crappy results too if I were aiming and hitting the shoulders of these animals. Shoulders aren't vitals. They are close to each other and both can be damaged in a single shot but shoulders are shoulders and vitals are vitals. I believe my success with the ELD line of bullets stems from shot placement. I always aim for the crease/vital area behind the shoulder. I've always thought it crazy to purposely shoot an animal in the very part I want to eat. The only way I'd do that is with a solid not made to fragment. Call me crazy. My $0.02.