I shoot carbons almost exclusively these days and all I own are trad bows. They are the most consistent in weight and spine, straightest, strongest, most forgiving, and quickest recovering from archers paradox material out there. The lure of the longbow is the simplicity of equipment and enriched experience of the hunt. What shaft material you use doesn't really change that for me, although I do enjoy making wood shafted arrows as a craft.
I've heard carbon arrows described as either "broken, lost or perfect" which can't be said for aluminum or wood.