Debating a soft shell

USMC-40

WKR
Joined
Nov 22, 2016
Messages
545
Location
NW Missouri
If you bring a hard shell and appropriate mid-layers - why do you pack a soft shell?

trying to get opinions on this...
 

ozyclint

WKR
Joined
Apr 27, 2012
Messages
1,745
Location
Queensland, Downunder
i used to but now i don't. now i have base layers, mid layers, puffy, shell. the puffy pants and jacket are slightly lighter than just the soft shell jacket. the puffy has a far better warmth to weight ratio.

to me, clothes are either to 1- wick moisture away from skin, 2- insulate or 3- offer wind and waterproofness. the puffy is a better insulator than the soft shell at far lighter pack weight.

i'll use a soft shell on day hunts where it's not cold enough to warrant the puffy and stalking into trad bow range is aided by the camo.
 
Joined
Apr 5, 2015
Messages
5,824
Interesting topic. Seems like there is a camp that thinks soft shells are too heavy for what they do. Others love them.

I tend to use my sitka jetstream quite a bit. From windy 60s to 20-30 with snow. Jack of all trades so to speak. However, I rarely carry a three layer goretex type hard shell unless I know I am going to get heavy rain. The soft shell sheds some and I use packable rain gear if I need more protection. I have come to really like, the wind proof ness of the soft shell and feel like I get chilled easily in windy conditions without a layer that can cut a cold breeze. I have played with soft shell vests as an option and also a thin soft shell / wind shirt like the sitka mountain jacket that cuts wind but has no insulation. I like the wind shirt idea but wish Sitka would put out a version with a hood.

Bottom line is if I were really, really counting ounces and depending on conditions, then my soft shell might not make the cut. However, it is on my back or in my pack/truck more often than not.
 
Last edited:
OP
USMC-40

USMC-40

WKR
Joined
Nov 22, 2016
Messages
545
Location
NW Missouri
I probably would not hunt for an extended period of time (more than a couple days) in the mountains without solid rain gear (Kuiu Yukon jacket, fjallraven whatever they are called pants) - to me, a decent mid layer should have some wind-stopping ability, therefore where does the soft-shell fit? Lots of guys love them, just curious as to what i am missing.
 

mtwarden

Super Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 18, 2016
Messages
9,487
Location
Montana
soft shell jackets typically don't breathe well enough, are heavy, not a substitute for dedicated rain gear, etc. If you had to pick one jacket to do it all, maybe- but I can't see a situation where that would ever be the case?

I like very light baselayers w/ a windshirt over the top if needed (these do breathe well, but still cut wind and light precipitation at a much lighter weight) or in cooler conditions w/ a mid-layer over the base or in addition to a windshirt.
 

nastynick

FNG
Joined
Jun 5, 2018
Messages
84
Location
Trondheim, Norway
I had 2 Kuiu guide jackets. One was camo for hunting other major brown for around town. It is such a styled jacket and the fit is phenomenal. That said, I sold my camo jacket as it didn’t cut wind as well as I wanted and used the money to buy a hard shell Kuiu Chucach. I still rock the brown one as my cool weather around town jacket. For me the soft shell just doesn’t do enough in the woods, even though I like them. I think it depends on the soft shell too. Not all are created equal.
 

tttoadman

WKR
Joined
Oct 3, 2013
Messages
1,735
Location
OR Hunter back in Oregon
I gave up the microfleece layer for a gore windstopper softshell jacket. I love it. If I need a little insulation, I have a synthetic vest to go under it. I never leave without my hard shell jackey and rain pants.
 
Joined
Sep 22, 2013
Messages
6,389
Timberline jacket replaced my soft shell but I still like the Shacket for archery spot & stalk.
 
Joined
Nov 16, 2017
Messages
8,161
Location
Central Oregon
I never take a softshell if "backpacking" in.
But I'll be honest I have to make myself leave it, because I love it.

My main use for it is if it is supposed to be below freezing all day and i will be on the move, and also need stealth.
It resists snow and wind well enough, has pit zips, and is mostly quiet. And super comfy.
But it has to stay below freezing.
 
Joined
Aug 25, 2015
Messages
536
Location
Wyoming
I'd rather beat the heck out of a softshell with a wind stopper barrier than a multi layer gore-tex rain shell on days when rain isn't actually a problem. Windy, snowy mornings I have a Timberline jacket I wear over an Uncompahgre and a grid fleece mid. Moves moisture away from me well enough and it's an amazing combination in wind.

My thought process is: every minute I'm wearing a waterproof shell when I don't need waterproof is one minute closer to it wetting out and failing when I do need waterproof.
 

Grizzly83

FNG
Joined
Mar 15, 2016
Messages
29
I generally think it’s pretty hard to beat the durability of a soft shell vs a puffy or rain gear outer layer, which is how I justify my soft shells. It’s hard to argue against a puffy and shell outer because of the versatility, but when you look at what good rain gear costs, it makes me nervous to brush bust or climb cliffs in it.

I’ve never considered a wind shirt (as mentioned above) and maybe I should be.... anyone have any recommendations for a good one?
 
Joined
Mar 11, 2017
Messages
753
I’ve got all the layers, but I don’t take them all on every trip. The puffy is for camp or glassing, after the pack comes off. I can hike with the pack while wearing the soft shell. The rain gear is only for extreme rain conditions (like SE Alaska) imo.

Sixsite gear made some pretty good USA softshell gear.
 

mtwarden

Super Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 18, 2016
Messages
9,487
Location
Montana
I generally think it’s pretty hard to beat the durability of a soft shell vs a puffy or rain gear outer layer, which is how I justify my soft shells. It’s hard to argue against a puffy and shell outer because of the versatility, but when you look at what good rain gear costs, it makes me nervous to brush bust or climb cliffs in it.

I’ve never considered a wind shirt (as mentioned above) and maybe I should be.... anyone have any recommendations for a good one?


I've got about a dozen of them :) For hunting I like either the Black Diamond Alpine Start or the Patagonia military one (can only be found on ebay, can't buy one from a store- well maybe an Army-Navy store).

Both breathe well while offering good wind and light precipitation resistance. Both are a heavier denier than most civilian offerings, little heavier obviously, but more suitable for hunting. Both are offered in muted colors.
 

Poser

WKR
Joined
Dec 27, 2013
Messages
5,033
Location
Durango CO
On cold weather hunts, I’ve gone consecutive days on end without taking a guide jacket off. I’ll put my puffy on over it for cold sits, unzip the pits for moving and sleep in it, too. In Oct and Nov, I’ll often not bring a rain jacket since it’s not going to snow at the elevations I’m hunting. It doesn’t go on every hunt, but I do find it to be a comfortable and versatile piece for the right conditions.
 

Tick

WKR
Joined
Jun 2, 2017
Messages
322
I use a soft shell in cold late season. A base and fleece under it keep me comfortable most of the time. Only put a down jacket over it while stopped.
 

Rock-o

WKR
Joined
Aug 15, 2019
Messages
649
On cold weather hunts, I’ve gone consecutive days on end without taking a guide jacket off. I’ll put my puffy on over it for cold sits, unzip the pits for moving and sleep in it, too.
I'm new to all this and have only purchased several clothing items at this point. This is going to be my initial approach.

The end of this past ski season in Tahoe was my first "experiment". Kuiu Ultra Merino 145 Zip-T, Kuiu Guide jacket and sometimes an inexpensive Columbia puffy. I was never cold - or even cool. Overall I was quite comfortable. Sometimes too hot.
 

thinhorn_AK

"DADDY"
Joined
Jul 2, 2016
Messages
10,341
Location
Alaska
I love my kuiu guide jacket for day hunts, boat and raft hunts but I don’t pack it if I’m back packing.
 

Roughout

FNG
Joined
May 14, 2014
Messages
93
I was in same boat last year. Flew up for first sheep hunt. Wore soft shell in travel. Was going to decide at last minute which to take up the hill. I put it on first morning in camp, over base layer, and basically didn’t take it back off until I was back in Oklahoma. Can not beat the durability and benefit of wind barrier. Every situation is different, all good thoughts here. If oz truly a priority, may have to leave behind. But I’d trust soft shell durability over rain gear for day in day out abuse and added benefit of insulation.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

Rommy

Lil-Rokslider
Joined
Jan 31, 2018
Messages
199
Location
phoenix arizona
I like the jetstream for more inactive hunts. Truck hunts, base camp hunts, day stand hunts, turkey hunts.

If I’m going to the backcountry then I’m definitely doing a puffy and rain jacket. The puffy and rain jacket combo is more versatile, warmer, and lighter.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Top