Is there anything you can do when you have a bad experience with a guide/outfitter?

Mykolaivka887

Well Known Rokslider
Joined
Jan 15, 2022
Messages
739
Under statute and regulation - 12 AAC 75.340 (f) (1) - it is illegal for a guide/outfitter to guarantee success or the number of animals to be killed. This does not apply to advertising past successes, either verbally or through marketing.
 

weekender7

Well Known Rokslider
Joined
Jun 3, 2018
Messages
622
Location
North Carolina
Sorry to hear about your botched hunt. Hunts like these don't come easy for most folks and it takes years to save and prep for them. You at least want to feel like you had a fair shake when you get done.
 

Farmer9770

Junior Member
Joined
Dec 14, 2020
Messages
33
Sorry you had a bad experience. Unfortunately I think this is going to be more common moving forward with the increase demand for guided hunts outfitters are naturally going to try to push more clients and raise prices. Considering the fact that a $20,000 hunt is a once in a lifetime event for most people pain of coming home empty-handed would sting more. It’s hard to separate the experience from a dollar amount when most people have to save for years to do something like that. No hunt is guaranteed but the spend that kind of money I would certainly want to think I at least had a decent chance at success . Only ever been on two guided hunts though so I really don’t have a lot of experience I much prefer to hunt on my own or with friends.
I guess at the end of the day before committing to a hunt like that one would need to ask themselves are you gonna be happy coming home empty-handed and if the answer is no then you probably shouldn’t go on that hunt to begin with.
 

mtnbiker208

Well Known Rokslider
Joined
Apr 4, 2017
Messages
659
Location
north idaho
at least you got to go.
I went to alaska do to a combo moose sheep hunt in 2012. The outfitter or guides never showed to his camp for the first 6 days of the hunt. I flew out on the 6th day. The Alaska Professional Hunters Assoc was a joke to work with. The good ole boy club at work. I did get my hunt cost back, but none of the other cost, ie planes, car rental, license fee, bush flights, ect. shit happens, move on and wish them bad luck.
 

Blockcaver

Well Known Rokslider
Joined
Sep 9, 2012
Messages
1,746
Location
BC
at least you got to go.
I went to alaska do to a combo moose sheep hunt in 2012. The outfitter or guides never showed to his camp for the first 6 days of the hunt. I flew out on the 6th day. The Alaska Professional Hunters Assoc was a joke to work with. The good ole boy club at work. I did get my hunt cost back, but none of the other cost, ie planes, car rental, license fee, bush flights, ect. shit happens, move on and wish them bad luck.
Sounds like a Shankster hunt. Had similar results with him in Alaska about 25 yrs ago. Turned me off guided hunts for 15 yrs.

That said there are excellent outfitters and guides out there! Chose carefully. And remember you are buying a hunt, not an animal.
 

Doc Holliday

Well Known Rokslider
Classified Approved
Joined
Jun 15, 2016
Messages
1,734
I could understand it happening if the guide and clients were from another outfitter, or some resident hunters came into the same drainage......IMO it seems like common sense for a big game hunt like this (boar grizz, bull moose, ram, etc,), that the outfitter should not send more than one of his guides/clients to same area unless there was a known concentration of game (ie: herd of caribou), and the guides were closely coordinating the effort. If the TV guys were given preference to hunt that drainage, then you and your guide should have been sent somewhere else, miles away in another direction. If the outfitter does not have enough wilderness for clients to have their own areas, then he simply took too many clients at the same time. I did kick the tires with Stephan Lake several years ago when I was looking to book a dall sheep hunt.....I ended up going to Canada, and after reading this, am glad I steered clear.
 

SuspiciousFish

Well Known Rokslider
Joined
May 26, 2022
Messages
162
That's not unethical. I don't think anything I read from you was unethical on their part. You may not agree with what they did but it's not unethical. I've seen a tendency in hunting forums to decree everything we don't like unethical. Unfair possibly in your eyes. If I set up my tent in the middle of where you're hunting it's not unethical. If you're eating dinner and i sit down at your table in a restaurant is it unethical? No. It's a dick move no doubt.

Now is it unethical to come onto a hunting forum, especially one that's built around DIY hunting and complain about a specific outfitter and name said outfitter in your very first post on said forum......

I agree. From the story the OP posted it was really only the other guide camp that was not a good call and it sounds like his guide was pissed about it. For the other points- Shooting a bear in a raging creek that would make it impossible to recover sounds very reasonable. Also holding a shot on a bear that looked marginally legal also seems like the wise decision.
 

Rich M

Well Known Rokslider
Joined
Jun 14, 2017
Messages
3,061
Location
Orlando
Sorry to hear about your botched hunt. Hunts like these don't come easy for most folks and it takes years to save and prep for them. You at least want to feel like you had a fair shake when you get done.

Excellent wording.

It did sound like a shit show.
 

sneaky

Well Known Rokslider
Joined
Feb 1, 2014
Messages
9,057
Location
ID
Man, I love new member drive by hit pieces! Al Gore's internet is awesome sometimes.
 
Top