Mountain Goat ID Quiz

[Yukondog]

Found this on CDOW site. I missed two. #4 and #11.

http://wildlife.state.co.us/SiteCollectionDocuments/DOW/Education/pdf/HunterEducation/MountainGoatIDQuizWEBRev09102010.pdf

 

[JPhelps]

I got them all right except the young billy in #4 (which to me is the same as a right answer). Now I just need to draw a tag.

 

[luke moffat]

Good find Yukon.

Alaska has one made up as well. The more you test yourself the better. Of course nothing beats practicing in the field, but can't always go do that.

http://www.adfg.alaska.gov/static/hunting/goathunting/pdfs/goat_long_quiz_for_web.pdf

 

[Yukondog]

Did better on the AK test. #4 and #10 where too hard to see.

Matt

 

[mattstanton]

missed 11, 12 and 16

 

[Rick Seymour]

I missed one...by pure luck. Perhaps I can carry that luck to the field as well....come-on TAG Gods

 

[bearguide]

fun quiz thanks / missed 3

 

[JDC]

Good test. I missed the four nannies with the kids. Should have thought about the kids and just gone with nannies.. Thanks Yukondog..

 

[slim9300]

That was perfect. I have always wondered how difficult it would be to tell the difference in a mature animal of either sex. It seems pretty easy now. I would say that a quality spotting scope is pretty crucial.

 

[Darin Cooper]

I had a nanny only tag in Utah a while back - a little practice in the field and you get it nailed down pretty quick! Lot easier to tell on a live goat than a sketch or photo.

[/IMG]

Scouted hard and took the oldest, longest horned gal on the mountain. 10 1/8"

 

[shanevg]

Nice got Darin! Did you ever score her? I've always wondered what a good 10" nanny would score. I kno of a couple here in WA that I think are pushing 12".

 

[slim9300]

Nice got Darin! Did you ever score her? I've always wondered what a good 10" nanny would score. I kno of a couple here in WA that I think are pushing 12".

Me too. I wish I was a B&C member and I could look at the roughly 100 book nannies and what their horn length was.

 

[Above Timber]

Good stuff. I did much better on the Alaska test that the Colorado test. I can see how an inexperienced hunter could miss identify the sex of a goat.

 

[Darin Cooper]

45 2/8" as I recall. I helped my buddy tag one even bigger 2 years after on the same hunt - a 10 5/8" Nanny that went 46 & 3/8 as I recall... We called her the Bananny! I will dig up a photo for reference.

 

[slim9300]

45 2/8" as I recall. I helped my buddy tag one even bigger 2 years after on the same hunt - a 10 5/8" Nanny that went 46 & 3/8 as I recall... We called her the Bananny! I will dig up a photo for reference.

Just wait until Shane posts the two nannies from his local unit. They are BEASTS and I'm sure are at least 11.5-12" if you can believe that. I have no doubt they would both make B&C.

Keep in mind that you can put in for this unit for 30 years and still have basically a 10% chance of drawing.

 

[75johndeere]

Got all but 18 right cant see that picture on my phone

 

[shanevg]

Just wait until Shane posts the two nannies from his local unit. They are BEASTS and I'm sure are at least 11.5-12" if you can believe that. I have no doubt they would both make B&C.

Keep in mind that you can put in for this unit for 30 years and still have basically a 10% chance of drawing.

Haha! 10% chance after 30 years? Fat chance. Last year max point holders ahead a 0.376% chance of drawing. If the same number of new applicants apply every year, the odds if drawing the tag would actually go down every year. Washington's draw system sucks!

 

[shanevg]

Here are pics of one of the big nannies we've been talking about:

 

[shanevg]

And here are some pics of the other nanny in reference.

 

[slim9300]

Haha! 10% chance after 30 years? Fat chance. Last year max point holders ahead a 0.376% chance of drawing. If the same number of new applicants apply every year, the odds if drawing the tag would actually go down every year. Washington's draw system sucks!

Max points is only 16 though this year right? Keep in mind that a lot of max points holders will eventually stop hunting.

I know. They need to allocate 50% of the special permit tags to those with max points. The problem is that there are so few tags. It won't fix the moose, sheep and goat draws, but it might fix the elk and deer.