WeiserBucks
WKR
Is there an insulated foam pad worth using for backpacking? I'm in the market for a pad and every inflatable I've had has leaked or down right popped at the worst time possible.
Closed cell is probably the way to go for backpacking. Unfortunately the tougher and more durable foam is the more uncomfortable it is to sleep on. An open cell memory foam mattress topper is super comfy, but heavy, and will soak up water for instance. A thermarest ridge rest or z is tough but I'm not tough enough to sleep on one night after night and get up feeling like hunting the next morning.
Another issue is R-value. You'll probably have to stack foam pads to get enough r value for nights below freezing.
I've been down the same thought process. I took a neoair x-therm this year for elk....and made sure I had the patch kit, PLUS I patted down the ground under it and removed sticks and stobs, AND I used a housewrap groundsheet. No problems.