Personally I like the SH Tommy for a hunting sight. It's not as light as the fast Eddie, but a little more durable and the gears aren't exposed. Hard mount, so not as heavy as the dovetailed Hogg Father.
But a lot of really good sights are available now. Pick one with the features you think are important. I go for 3rd axis adjustment and durability. Pin brightness hasn't been a big factor for me with a hunting sight, pins too bright and I have trouble seeing what I'm aiming at in low light, but if hunting out of blinds it can be a big factor.
I like that with a Tommy or a Hogg Father I can use the sight scale to produce a yard tape for the sight. Not a big deal, but just a matter of convenience for me. I don't think think there's many hunting sights that have a scale.