I'd recommend you take every one of the recommendations you'll get with a grain of salt and try on as many brands/sizes as possible. For instance, the 1 shot gear crew may love the Kenetrek's, but I know quite a few guys you couldn't pay to wear them (myself included).
GoHunt has been my go to place for footwear, recently. Take the time to do their foot measurement procedure and compare it against the foot profiles they have for the individual boots. I've had great luck with it for two pairs now, and their CS has been top notch.
I'll throw my current favorite pair of boots into the mix because I haven't seen it mentioned yet, Hanwag Alverstone's.
Good luck!