fillthefreezer
WKR
fair enough. you have alot more experience with these shelters than i doI think the tipis are cool because of the shape. They shed wind better in my opinion.
Maybe Patrick can comment, but I'm pretty sure the sawtooth was invented after he got tired of crawling into the super tarp. He used the super tarp solo a lot. The sawtooth is similar in shape to the super but with an enclosed front and walk in room.
The sawtooth by no means replaces the 4 man. But is just another tool in the tool belt of shelters you can have.