I bought the beartooth last year before the season and put about 100ish miles on them mostly elk, antelope and bird hunting. Fits great, feels great, I did not have a break in period, felt great for me right out of the box. With that said I usually do not have issues with my feet fitting anything, so I'm pretty lucky there. They seemed to wear fine too, no major problems with them, seem to be a high quality built product. I also put in a 3rd party insole, I don't think any boot comes with a decent one.
I live in Bozeman, so went to Schnees and I tried on the Absaroka and Granite as well, both are stiffer. But I wanted the 200g insulation so went with the Beartooth and after talking with the sales guy it seemed the Beartooth was what would be best for my type of hunting. Gave me plenty of support for the terrain I was in. I'm not sheep/goat hunting so didn't need that extra stiffness. I was coming from the Danner Pronghorn so it was a great upgrade. I have not tried the Salomon or Tibets so no help there, lots of people like them on here though.