Just opened up that Excel spreadsheet. The order above is about right. My 44 loads according to the program get only about 30% more penetration rather than 100% more as I thought. I'm still thinking they do better than 30%. 9, 45 Super/ACP are really close. 10mm maybe 10% more than those two.
But again, I've seen test results showing those reversed.
...And I'm sure my program is at least as accurate as the climate modeling has been, so far, fwiw.
I'll look for that gelatin testing, but in the meantime, this was kind of interesting, and reminded me how well the Federal 147 FMJ FP seem to penetrate.
Bottom line, IMO. If you want an autoloader for woods carry, pick a 45/10/9 you like and shoot well and live long and prosper. There's just not that much difference.