Arctic Air DIY Caribou Hunt Kotzebue in depth review with map

Otty0914

FNG
Joined
Nov 5, 2019
Messages
28
Here is my review of our experience with Arctic Air Service:

The attached map gives a little insight on most of the events discussed in this review. The pin is our camp, the green diamonds are approximate locations of the other 4 camps around us based on where I saw them in relation to other terrain features I could identify. The blue diamonds are the approximate location where I viewed other hunters in the spotting scope. The red diamonds are our 2 glassing locations, and the orange trail is our approximate travel path.

We booked this hunt after my first hunt with arctic air in 2020 while owned by Sheila and Mike that was a fantastic experience. My wife and I harvested bulls and caught a countless number of graylings, saw moose, bears, northern lights and just had the textbook flawless trip that met every one of our expectations.

Obviously with the GMU closure the hunt was postponed and we opted to keep our dates to be rescheduled. Our options were to hold the dates and reschedule when possible or walk away from the 50% deposit already paid. I was contacted by the new owner Gary Colbath in February of this year to discuss new dates. He was able to schedule our hunt and honor our deposit and even credit us more for our father who was supposed to go with us but couldn’t due to medical issues. So he rolled our fathers deposit onto our remaining balance and we paid the remaining amount. For that I was very thankful. Now that you have a little back story on how we got to this point here is my review of the arrival, drop-off in the field, hunting, and extraction from the field.

Hunt Dates 9/11-9/18

Arrival to Kotzebue on 9/10 at 12:35pm, Gary, Bruce, and Cree from Arctic Air met us and 10 other clients (Parties of 2 (My Brother and I), 2, 4, and 4) at the airport and assisted us with getting everything to the hotel with an orientation meeting at 7pm on the 3rd floor of the Nullagvik hotel. This orientation covers all paperwork and verification of licenses and tags along with what to expect for fly-in and fly-out days. What communications to expect from the transporter and what weather communication are going to be expected from you. Gary also covers bear safety and what is expected if a mistake is made in the field ex: shooting a cow you thought was a bull or shooting a bear in self-defense. All good information.

9/11 – Communication was sent out at 8am that they were waiting for weather to clear and to meet in the hotel lobby at 10am for more information. At 10am my group (My brother and I) and another group of 4 was selected to stage at the airport for flights into the field. Once arrived the group of 4 loaded into 2 planes and took off. My brother and I thought for a while that this flight wasn’t going to happen due to weather rolling through the area. The other 2 transporter groups (Ram and another group I don’t know the name of) were packing up and calling it a day but we were still holding on. Soon Gary showed up and gave us fist bumps saying we are going hunting! 2 pilots showed up unloaded some hunters that were not successful and loaded our gear into the planes and we were off to the field at 7pm landing at 8pm on a gravel bar indicated on the map. It was a rush to get camp set up and get some water and food before calling it a night dreaming of a giant herd of bulls ready for harvesting the next day.

9/12 – Day 1 hunting – We woke up and grabbed our packs that were feverishly worked on the night before in preparation for the day. We worked up to a high spot in the tundra to glass the valley keeping our creek bottom in sight due to the amount of tracks seen there. The day brought a sighting of a bull 2 miles away that went to our north away from us but would have never been able to catch up with. We also glasses 6 other hunters… Realizing we were set down near a camp only 400yds to our north on the opposite side of the river and a camp to our south apparently on a ridge top approximately 1 mile away.

9/13 – Day 2 hunting – We woke up to go back to our glassing spot thinking if we beat everyone out early we might catch some caribou that have filtered into the area before other camps can get to them. Day 2 brought no caribou sighting but now 7 hunters scattered on every ridgetop around us. Frustration set in and we headed to camp and I sent Gary a message at 7:29pm that read, “Only 1 caribou sighting, saw 6 hunters on day 1 and 7 hunters today.” His response, “Yikes. Must be Ram guys I think, we only have one camp anywhere close to you? Keep hunting – in that area for a reason” After some discussion we decided if the caribou aren’t coming to us we will go to them. We selected a distant hill about 3 miles from camp. Realizing it would take a great effort to get there it was early to bed then off to that hill early in the morning.

9/14 – Day 3 hunting – We set out for the new glassing spot passing by our neighbors camp of 5 hunters to our north. In route we encounter a group of 20 cows and calves. Making it to our mountain by 11am. We were really searching that group for any bull that costed us about an hour or 2 in our travel. Once behind the glass on our new glassing knoll it was evident that this hunt was going to be more about beating other hunters when I glassed 2 more camps to our north on the same river bottom, we were located on. This brought our total to 4 camps besides ours with 2 tents each indicating more than 2 hunters. After more glassing it was confirmed that each camp had 4 hunters. So, in order from south to north along this river bottom there was my brother and I, a camp of 5 - 400 yds north, and about another half mile up a camp of 4 and another mile up another camp of 4. Leaving the other camp to our south on the ridge with at least 3 confirmed but based on the number of planes that landed days after it required 3 planes to extract them with my guess being a group of 5.

9/15 – Day 4 hunting – We set out for our glassing knoll knowing that at this point we needed luck to bring a bull to us and even if we harvest one that it will be one hell of a pack job getting it back. Both of us were sore from the day before but found an alternate route that would alleviate some of the tundra walking. It worked out and we were on our glassing knoll by 9am. Glassing some nice bulls 3-5 miles away and staying a safe distance away from the river bottom lined with camps. We did see a group of bulls to our north about 3 miles away on the opposite side of the river. While watching this group I observed 3 dots stalking up on them and harvesting a couple from the group. The remaining bulls spooked out of the valley after they shot. Towards the end of the day we spotted a lone cow that picked up the attention of a bull and they slowly started working their way towards us from about 3 miles away. Getting rather excited we watched and planned how we would get off our knoll and cut them off. When they were about a mile and a half away we began to descend off our hill top when a bush plane flew over the ridgetop and dropped into the far camp for extraction of the hunters. This spooked the cow and the bull followed both running in the opposite direction of us… That day both northern most camps were removed from the field. We felt that maybe this would offer us a better chance to have a herd move down the river to our location.

9/16 – Day 5 hunting – We put all our eggs in that glassing knoll basket, knowing this would be our last day to attempt to harvest from that spot as a one day pack out would not be possible with our energy level and terrain. Day 5 brought 1 bull sighting 4 miles away and moving west away from our location. On our return trip to camp that evening we met our neighbors to the north about 400yds. A camp of 5 that had the same luck we did. No caribou but sightings that were out of hunting range. We asked them who they were hunting with and there response was Arctic Air. Our transporter dropped us right next to one of his other camps and thought it would be ok to do so just because they were on the other side of the river. This river at its current level could be crossed but we never did out of consideration for that camp.

9/17 – Day 6 hunting – We decided to glass from our high spot close to camp in hopes that now all camps to the north have been removed might bring caribou into our valley but nothing was seen and we enjoyed a relaxing camp day getting ready to be flown from the field the following day.

9/18 – Day 7 Extraction Day – Gary was requesting information on weather it was favorable for flying and we had a plane to our location by about noon or 1. Pilots Steve and Clay were great, always worried about our comfort on the flight ensuring everyone was ok giving a thumbs up every so often. You can tell they were all very skilled and experienced pilots which brought a calmness over me seeing as though I hate heights and see flying as just a necessary evil to do this hunt. Our return to the hotel offered us the opportunity to talk with other hunters and the consistent theme was viewing a few other hunters but most were very alarmed to hear of the 18 other hunters encountered in our area. Consensus was this is their last trip with Arctic Air as it will be my last as well.

Continued in next comment section.
 
OP
Otty0914

Otty0914

FNG
Joined
Nov 5, 2019
Messages
28
I hope this in-depth review of our trip helps someone in the future. This was kind of a messed-up deal with everything leading up to the planning and execution of the trip. GMU closures, deposits, ownership change, my suggestion is to for sure spend the money on trip insurance and I know there is never going to be a transporter contract that is in your full favor but discuss how close they set camps. In conversation going back to the hotel we were told the success rate has now fallen from 85% 2 weeks ago to hovering in the 60’s and my projection is probably falling. It seemed like Gary’s biggest concern was just dropping people where they could so that the planes are full going out and full coming back getting the most bang for their buck not actually worrying about getting you on the game. When they dropped us off they jumped up the gravel bar to our immediate south maybe 200yds and picked up a group of 4 to fly out.

The previous owners had a good success rate and discussing with them it was always about 85% for the season. I inquired about the other 15% and was told that is most time guys trying to bow hunt, looking for a particular trophy ex. Big tops, double shovels, etc… or people that don’t have the physical ability to hunt far from camp. Us not being picky and in fairly good shape hunting with rifles had no problems harvesting 2 nice (to us) bulls.
 

Akselaken

FNG
Joined
Oct 27, 2021
Messages
18
Im not so sure we were to the north of you 9/9-15. We shot 4 but didnt see much on our last 2 days.
 
OP
Otty0914

Otty0914

FNG
Joined
Nov 5, 2019
Messages
28
It seemed the majority of the caribou we saw were north of us 5-6 miles from our camp. With the wind blowing from the east a majority of the time maybe the scent of the line of camps between us may have prevented them from moving down the river. Most we saw were moving west.
 

MRosdahl

FNG
Joined
Jun 1, 2023
Messages
5
It seemed the majority of the caribou we saw were north of us 5-6 miles from our camp. With the wind blowing from the east a majority of the time maybe the scent of the line of camps between us may have prevented them from moving down the river. Most we saw were moving west.
I (hopefully not unfortunately) will be hunting with AA next year at essentially the same dates as you guys did. Would you mind sharing a bit more info on where they ended up flying you guys out to?
 

Matt79

Lil-Rokslider
Joined
Mar 3, 2018
Messages
178
Location
Michigan
I don’t like hearing any of these stories, as we are booked with them in 2025
 
Joined
Dec 7, 2021
Messages
54
Think this is gonna be the reality of caribou hunting up out of Kotzebue for as long as that closure is there. There’s simply not enough land/area/places to land. It’s a small area for a high demand hunt. What should be a 95% hunt is gonna be 50-60% and it’s a bummer


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

Scottf270

WKR
Joined
Sep 26, 2017
Messages
495
Location
Missouri
If it's such a cluster, why don't the flight services show some restraint and not overbook or burden the resource. All they are doing is screwing people out of their money and hurting the game and area? Is it all greed?
 
Joined
Dec 7, 2021
Messages
54
If it's such a cluster, why don't the flight services show some restraint and not overbook or burden the resource. All they are doing is screwing people out of their money and hurting the game and area? Is it all greed?

That ones beyond my scope


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Joined
Nov 3, 2017
Messages
1,472
Location
AK
If it's such a cluster, why don't the flight services show some restraint and not overbook or burden the resource. All they are doing is screwing people out of their money and hurting the game and area? Is it all greed?
With very few exceptions, transporters/outfitters/guides operate with nearly no restriction in AK besides the ones they place on themselves. It gets worse on state land as is now the case in GMU23. On some level, everyone’s expectation of a hunt are different and every area has a different density. SOA puts the burden on the hunter to do that due diligence, and as long as the outfitter didn’t lie about the service provided or not fulfill a promise, I suppose it’s all fair game. I’m morally split between protecting people that have been mislead or from overbooked outfitters by putting some sort of number or group quota for an area or more field distance separation rules and my preference for less regulation and letting capitalism run its course. For now, I mostly prefer less regulation and wish they would all work together and self regulate. But that’s in direct opposition of human nature unfortunately.

I talked to 3 groups totaling 8 guys at the airport a couple weeks ago. Between the three groups, one 35” bull was shot. One group never saw a bull. One group had the same outfitter they used drop a camp on an adjacent lake. We all understand animals do what they want, hunting isn’t guaranteed, and AK can be the land of feast and famine. I’ve been on several hunts where I never saw a legal animal, but that was a known risk for the area and species. But if someone were sold a hunt in the highest moose density area in the continent and those were the results, you can be the judge as to where that falls on the ethics spectrum. Same with stacking hunters as the OP outlined. What we do about it remains grey.
 
Joined
Aug 12, 2014
Messages
13
Maybe my expectations for this type of hunt were too high. I expected to at least see a caribou while flying.

I also didn't expect to find myself to be on tribal lands less than a half mile from camp. That was pure negligence by Russ Meyer, Kyle Hanson, Gary Colbath and the pilots who dropped us in camp.
 
Joined
Jun 3, 2020
Messages
619
Location
Eagle River, AK
Was it tribal corporation land or a native allotments? Native allotments are always being created. They can be as urban as off the highway or as remote as BFA. I bet if there was caribou walking through your camp you wouldnt have cared if you were 100 yards from a native allotment. Transporters are booked years in advance from what it sounds like. So if they limit the amount of hunters you might as well double the wait time and then the cost is going to go way up as well since they are putting less hunters in the field. They also have to have some type of ethics and not stack people on top of each other which seems to be a problem since the federal land closures.

If there were thousands of caribou i am sure you wouldnt have cared so much about those other people around, caribou are going to caribou and to try to predict exactly where they are going to be is impossible because not even the caribou knows what its going to do 2 seconds from now.
 

fngTony

Super Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Jan 18, 2016
Messages
5,123
Had to remove several comments, please be mindful about the specific information you share.
 
Joined
Aug 12, 2014
Messages
13
Sorry, I posted the location where we were dropped 50 miles south of any caribou being taken. Gary Colbath, Russ Meyer, and Kyle Hanson didn’t give a damn about where were dropped why should anyone else?
 
Top